Scarcity: In The Eye Of The Collector? The Rise Of Artificial Scarcity  

By Tom Ruggie

Published on Forbes.com
2/23/2026

Scarcity is the driving force behind value for much of the collectibles ecosystem. However, scarcity comes in many forms, and record prices in some categories are rewriting the rulebook in real time.

As a lifelong collector of baseball cards, I’ve watched as the treasures of my youth evolved into vintage artifacts. The supply of those 1950s and 1960s cards diminished quickly as children, blissfully unaware of their future value, played with them; I committed my own collecting gaffes by using rubber bands to organize my cards by team. As years passed, poorly stored cards declined in condition or met an unceremonious end in the dumpster.

The passage of time has resulted in an incredible scarcity of mint-condition cards. PSA has authenticated over 320,000 cards from the 1952 Topps set. Of those, a mere 94 (0.02%) have received a PSA 10 and only 1,723 (0.5%) have received a PSA 9.

Consequently, the most pristine cards command incredible prices. There are only six PSA 9 Mickey Mantle cards from that set. In 2021, the last time one was sold, the price tag was $5.2 million. Industry experts estimate that the three PSA 10s are worth more than $30 million each.

What’s fascinating, though, is that a Mantle rookie card is no longer the most expensive sports card ever sold. It was replaced atop the throne in 2025 in part because scarcity can be manufactured.

Investment advisory services offered through Destiny Family Office, LLC, an SEC Registered Investment Advisor. Rankings and/or recognition by unaffiliated rating services and/or publications should not be construed by a client or prospective client as a guarantee that he/she will experience a certain level of results if Destiny Family Office or its firms are engaged, nor should it be construed as a current or past endorsement of Destiny Family Office.