In my work as a family office advisor, I frequently field questions from clients about two seemingly unrelated subjects: how to manage complex collections of passion assets and how to prepare for the age of artificial intelligence. Recently, I’ve realized that these two topics are more related than they first appear. The rise of AI will have massive implications for collectors of physical assets, and it will shape collectible markets for decades to come.
Scarce physical assets will grow in appeal.
We’re entering an age of digital abundance, where previously unfathomable knowledge sits a button click away and where that knowledge can be deployed to quickly build things that would’ve required significant time and manpower in eras past.
AJ Scaramucci, who bought the $16.5 million Pokémon Pikachu Illustrator card, believes AI will allot humans more time to spend on self-actualization. “When humans self-actualize, when they are post-scarcity, what do they do? They pick up hobbies,” Scaramucci explained on my podcast. “My thesis is that a lot of investment value is going to accrue into all of those areas: areas of self-actualization, particularly areas where there are scarce assets.”
Even the world’s top venture capital firms are recognizing a shift. For instance, Thrive Capital recently launched Thrive Eternal, a permanent capital holding company that, rather than investing in tech, is investing specifically in “assets with qualities that cannot be replicated by technology,” pursuing iconic franchises and cultural institutions that compound through cultural resonance. That vehicle’s first investment was the San Francisco Giants. Treasured collectibles share many of the same properties as sports franchises, just on a smaller scale, appreciating due to their rare combination of scarcity and cultural resonance.
When digital capability becomes commoditized, incremental value shifts to scarce physical assets with cultural value. An arms race will rise between authenticators and counterfeiters.
Authentication is already improving with AI assistance, which recognizes patterns and inconsistencies that sometimes evade the human eye. Leading trading card authenticators have integrated AI into their processes, and over time, I believe it will bear greater responsibility in authentication and grading services.
But just as AI will likely help produce better authentication, it will inevitably also help bad actors create superior forgeries. Not only could it play a role in producing fake items themselves, but it could also assist in producing fake evidence: certificates of authenticity, letters of provenance and photographs, for example. That malfeasance is already occurring in the art market, and bad actors have descended on the sports memorabilia market as well, doctoring photographs in one instance to seek authentication of a purportedly game-worn Michael Jordan jersey. AI will only make schemes like those easier to execute more convincingly.
Authenticators, then, must remain one step ahead of their adversaries, investing in their capabilities to prepare for the barrage of nefarious submissions to follow. Trust becomes that much more important across the collectibles landscape, potentially lifting authentication costs for high-value items.
Rich human provenance will become even more important.
In an era when trust matters more than ever, a verifiable, bulletproof chain of provenance becomes incredibly valuable. Knowing where an asset has been, with no gaps, minimizes the likelihood of integrity loss. Perhaps more importantly, though, the human aspect of provenance will convey even greater value and meaning.
As AI makes it easier to manufacture convincing synthetic information, not all chains of provenance will be trustworthy. But when there’s a credible human aspect to that provenance, our ability to trust it increases. For instance, an item owned by a music icon’s longtime manager or family, or a jersey that comes straight from the player themself or their teammate: These are the items that will rise to the top of the market.
Similarly, incremental value will accrue to items owned by credible collectors who are respected within their collecting communities. Fellow collectors will trust their taste, their eye for authenticity and their integrity. In a world of seamless digital transactions and endless digital records, a touch of humanity will go even further than it does now.
Markets will grow more efficient.
While pricing tools and databases have matured in recent years, AI’s ability to ingest and apply massive amounts of data and information will drive dramatic improvements. Consider the various inputs that could create far more accurate real-time pricing estimates: auction results, population reports, macroeconomic data, social media sentiment, available listings, images, condition reports… and that’s barely scratching the surface.
Suddenly, pricing tools don’t just regurgitate the last five auction sales without any associated context. Instead, they know how the current asset compares to those sales in condition and eye appeal, how the market has changed since those sales, how the economy has shifted and more.
That information will be readily available to prospective consignors and bidders alike. Seasoned collectors will be sad to see this next part: The days of easy arbitrage are over. Information asymmetries, the disparate nature of collectible markets and market illiquidity created frequent mis-pricings, allowing savvy collectors to acquire desirable assets at discounts. But in a world where informational gaps vanish, so do many of those opportunities.
The flip side of that development is that the market’s increased efficiency, its ability to reflect available information, lowers the barriers to entry for new collectors and for investors. In a more efficient market, the capacity of these assets to become financialized and investable increases.
The age of AI is upon us. In this era of digital abundance, we could hold physical scarcity even more dearly. That shift will give rise to a vastly more sophisticated collectibles market, one that covets authenticity and behaves efficiently. But at the root of that market, accruing the most value, will be the assets with the most compelling and profoundly human stories to tell.
Investment advisory services offered through Destiny Family Office, LLC, an SEC Registered Investment Advisor. Rankings and/or recognition by unaffiliated rating services and/or publications should not be construed by a client or prospective client as a guarantee that he/she will experience a certain level of results if Destiny Family Office or its firms are engaged, nor should it be construed as a current or past endorsement of Destiny Family Office.


