Scarcity is the driving force behind value for much of the collectibles ecosystem. However, scarcity comes in many forms, and record prices in some categories are rewriting the rulebook in real time.
As a lifelong collector of baseball cards, I’ve watched as the treasures of my youth evolved into vintage artifacts. The supply of those 1950s and 1960s cards diminished quickly as children, blissfully unaware of their future value, played with them; I committed my own collecting gaffes by using rubber bands to organize my cards by team. As years passed, poorly stored cards declined in condition or met an unceremonious end in the dumpster.
The passage of time has resulted in an incredible scarcity of mint-condition cards. PSA has authenticated over 320,000 cards from the 1952 Topps set. Of those, a mere 94 (0.02%) have received a PSA 10 and only 1,723 (0.5%) have received a PSA 9.
Consequently, the most pristine cards command incredible prices. There are only six PSA 9 Mickey Mantle cards from that set. In 2021, the last time one was sold, the price tag was $5.2 million. Industry experts estimate that the three PSA 10s are worth more than $30 million each.
What’s fascinating, though, is that a Mantle rookie card is no longer the most expensive sports card ever sold. It was replaced atop the throne in 2025 in part because scarcity can be manufactured.
Artificial Scarcity: Examples And Trends
In August, a rare sports card featuring “Logoman” jersey patches and autographs from both Michael Jordan and Kobe Bryant sold for $12.9 million. Upper Deck produced the card, a one-of-one, in 2007, cutting the Logoman patches from game-used jerseys. Notably, it sold for more than any entire Jordan or Bryant game-worn jersey ever has; even Jordan’s 1998 Finals jersey sold for less ($10.1 million).
Logo patches across sports are often found in the most coveted modern cards, sitting atop a hierarchy of attributes that includes jersey patches, autographs and “parallel” prints. These products emerged in the aftermath of the Junk Wax Era of the late 1980s and 1990s, when overproduction and subsequent market saturation devastated the industry. By creating select, limited products, manufacturers could give collectors coveted prizes to chase while still selling endless cases of cards.
There’s an artificiality to the scarcity of these products; it’s based on a manufacturing decision rather than organic factors. Though it may befuddle vintage collectors like me, demand is not shying away from that more artificial brand of scarcity.
To illustrate, according to data from CardLadder.com (registration required), 28 cards sold for more than $1 million in 2025. Of those, 18 were produced after the turn of the millennium, and 16 were cards featuring patches.
Collectors could very well replicate these cards for cheaper than the real thing, exploiting a counterintuitive market dynamic that sees full game-worn jerseys often sell for markedly less than patch cards. Ironically, the card companies’ choice to cut up game-worn jerseys reduces their supply, which makes the pricing discrepancy even more counterintuitive.
If collectors could replicate the products, so too could the card companies, likely with greater ease. They’re stopped primarily by fears of market saturation. But is that enough reassurance to spend seven figures on a card?
Topps’ recent initiatives demonstrate an evolution of the industry’s understanding of more organic forms of scarcity and a commercial ability to leverage them. The company has popularized “Debut” patches, worn on a player’s jersey during his professional debut and later removed (leaving the jersey itself intact) and included in a card. A player debuts only once, meaning this card isn’t easily replicated or substituted. The company has leveraged materials from other specific games and moments to enhance a card’s appeal in less fungible ways.
Implicit in these decisions is the recognition that artificial scarcity, leveraged haphazardly, is fraught with risk for collectors and manufacturers alike.
Artificial scarcity as a marketing strategy is not exclusive to sports cards. Luxury brands like Rolex in watches and Hermès in handbags produce many of their goods in quantities overwhelmed by demand. But when market conditions soften, the carefully crafted supply-demand imbalance can tilt.
For instance, according to data from WatchCharts, secondary market prices for Rolex watches have fallen nearly 30% from their 2022 peak. Similarly, a Bernstein report finds that average resale premiums (the ratio of auction prices to retail prices) for Birkin and Kelly bags have fallen from 2.2 times in 2022 to 1.4 times at the end of 2025. These falling premiums can weaken the items’ desirability, further weighing on primary and secondary market demand.
Takeaways For Collectors
The financial lessons for collectors are clear. First, collectors should be aware of the nature of their items’ scarcity and the durability of that scarcity. Do their items face supply risk in the future, and are there viable collecting substitutes for their items? The existence of an abundant supply, whether now or later, threatens value and could hasten a collector’s plans to relinquish items.
Similarly, collectors should recognize the changing tastes that accompany demographic shifts. As younger generations come into wealth, their collecting interests may differ from those of their elders. Perhaps Mickey Mantle cards will long remain in vogue, but demand can shift at the margins, popularizing creations like patch cards of more recent athletes while the lesser stars of bygone eras fade.
When planning for the future, collectors must reckon with their items’ ability to stand the test of time. This is true not only of sports memorabilia but of fine art and other categories. Art collectors recognize the performance of Modern art, Impressionism and Old Masters has lagged far behind Contemporary art in recent decades, according to recent reports on art as an asset class.
As always, beauty is in the eye of the beholder. But to be more specific in this era, scarcity is in the eye of the collector.
Investment advisory services offered through Destiny Family Office, LLC, an SEC Registered Investment Advisor. Rankings and/or recognition by unaffiliated rating services and/or publications should not be construed by a client or prospective client as a guarantee that he/she will experience a certain level of results if Destiny Family Office or its firms are engaged, nor should it be construed as a current or past endorsement of Destiny Family Office.


